In How the South Won the Civil War, Heather Cox Richardson traces how the ideological foundation of the antebellum South—marked by a commitment to white supremacy, economic inequality, and oligarchic rule—survived the Civil War and found fertile ground in the American West. She connects the post-war expansion westward with the spread of Southern ideologies, which melded with Western myths of rugged individualism and freedom, creating a socio-political legacy that shapes modern American conservatism.
Key Themes and Arguments
-
The Confederate Ideology in the West: Richardson argues that after the Civil War, many Southerners moved West, where they continued to uphold racial and economic hierarchies. The West, like the South, relied on exploitative labor—Native Americans were displaced, Black Americans were restricted from land ownership, and non-white labor was frequently used under harsh conditions. Richardson posits that this racial hierarchy, combined with anti-government sentiment, mirrored the antebellum South’s structures, where white elites retained control by excluding other groups from economic and political power
. -
Myth of the Cowboy and Individualism: The myth of the American cowboy, Richardson explains, became central to Western (and eventually national) identity. This figure represented self-sufficiency, resilience, and freedom—ideals that ignored the fact that these freedoms often came at the expense of marginalized groups. The cowboy’s rugged individualism, celebrated in Western popular culture, was largely an illusion. Federal policies, such as land grants and subsidies, had facilitated Western expansion and prosperity, contradicting the idea that settlers succeeded purely on personal merit
. -
The South-West Alliance in Politics: This alliance solidified in the late 20th century, with political leaders like Ronald Reagan symbolically uniting Southern and Western conservative ideologies. Reagan’s declaration of “states’ rights” at the start of his campaign in Mississippi exemplified this connection. Richardson argues that this period saw the rise of a new conservative movement, one that emphasized anti-government rhetoric and “freedom” for elites, while often rolling back policies that supported racial and economic equality. This conservative ethos, she argues, allowed the South’s hierarchical, oligarchic structure to reassert itself nationally by promoting limited government, deregulation, and tax cuts that benefited the wealthy and corporate interests
. -
Contemporary Parallels and the Legacy of Inequality: Richardson draws explicit parallels between 19th-century Southern oligarchy and modern populism, suggesting that figures like Donald Trump echo the Confederacy’s anti-democratic spirit by invoking racial and cultural fears to rally support. This continuation of “us versus them” politics, often framed as protecting “American values,” perpetuates the same racial and class-based divisions that characterized the Confederate cause. She points out that these ideologies, despite the North’s Civil War victory, never fully disappeared but were instead reconfigured to resonate within the Western frontier mythology and later, mainstream American politics
.
Conclusion
Richardson's book challenges the traditional narrative of the Civil War’s aftermath by showing how the ideologies that supported the Confederacy adapted and endured in the American West and, eventually, in the broader conservative movement. She suggests that understanding this history is essential to addressing the racial and economic divides in contemporary America.
How the South Won the Civil War is a thought-provoking historical examination that emphasizes how regional myths and ideologies have a lasting impact on national identity and policy, echoing through both past and present American life.